I wasn't getting any more votes and the results were pretty clear. Thanks to those who voted. Please let me know if you want another round.

Banners will be posted in a separate post sometime soon.

( .....and the last icon maker standing for round #9 is.....Collapse )

Hey everyone. I really need more votes to be able to post the results. I will hopefully be able to end voting tomorrow (16th) at 11PM EST.

bangel_4e did not enter so I am just going ahead with the final two. Good luck!

Rules:
1. Keep your icon identity hidden until after the results are posted. Don't vote for yourself or get anybody to vote for you.
2. Vote on quality, not preference.
3. Vote for your favorite for each part.
4. If you entered, do not vote.
5. Reasons are optional but nice.

( voting under the cut for challenge #4 - finalCollapse )

Voting will end on Sunday, April 14th at around 9 PM EST or when I get at least 5 votes. Comments are screened.

This is the final reminder that Challenge #4 ends shortly, Sunday, April 7 at 11 PM EST.

Please remember you can not skip this round since it is the last one. If you need a few extra days, please let me know!!

I still need icons from:
lukecanwaltz88 & bangel_4e

Just a reminder that Challenge #4 ends shortly, Sunday, April 7 at 11 PM EST.

Please remember you can not skip this round since it is the last one.

I still need icons from:
lukecanwaltz88 & bangel_4e

Congrats to the final three. Final challenge behind the cut.

( challenge #04 under hereCollapse )

I still only had a few votes but I am going to post the results anyways. Thanks for voting.

Eliminated:
by stolenglimpse with -3 votes

Sorry to see you go!

Community's Choice:
by dance_the_dance with +3.

Chosen One (mod's choice):
by stolenglimpse. I liked the muted coloring.

Banners will be posted at the end of the round.

( tally behind the cutCollapse )

Hey everyone. I really need more votes to be able to post the results. I will hopefully be able to end voting tomorrow (28th) at 9PM EST.

Just a reminder that Challenge #3 voting ends on Saturday, March 23rd, at around 10 PM EST You can vote here.

Thank you for the lovely entries!

Skipping: bangel_4e

Rules:
1. Keep your icon identity hidden until after the results are posted. Don't vote for yourself or get anybody to vote for you.
2. Vote on quality, not preference. Actually think about why you are voting the icons out. It is too plain, too sharp, or it is boring are not good enough reasons to vote an icon out. If your opinion is that the icon is too sharp, explain where and/or why is it to sharp. Why is it a bad thing? Be specific without being rude. Examples on how to vote are under the cut as is a few links of helpful tips.
3. Vote for 1 icon that you feel is the worst quality of the bunch. You are also voting for 1 favorite icon. Voting is weighed.
4. If you are apart of the round, please vote.

( voting under the cut for challenge #03Collapse )

Voting will end Saturday, March 23rd, at around 10 PM EST